NEW YORK—Vision-Ease Lens, a unit of Insight Equity A.P. X. LP,
is suing Transitions Optical for allegedly monopolizing the market for
photochromic spectacle lenses.
In a complaint filed July 27 in the United States District Court
for the District of Delaware, Vision-Ease claims that Transitions
Optical controls more than 85 percent of the photochromic lens market.
The complaint alleges that Transitions violated U.S. antitrust laws and
Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act by engaging in
“anticompetitive acts to maintain monopoly power and unfairly restrain
trade in the photochromic ophthalmic lens market.” Vision-Ease claims
that Transitions’ actions have reduced competition, raised prices, and
restricted output.
According to the court documents, “Transitions’ anticompetitive
acts have harmed the public by causing higher prices and reducing
offerings for photochromic ophthalmic lenses, stifling product research
and development, and raising barriers of entry to prevent competition.
Transitions’ acts have harmed Vision-Ease by hindering or preventing
Vision-Ease from marketing and selling photochromic lenses in
competition with Transitions’ photochromic lenses.”
Additionally, the Vision-Ease complaint claims that “Transitions has maintained its monopoly power by engaging in a variety of actions which…thwarted competition
and foreclosed substantial portions of the retail and wholesale
distribution channels.” Vision-Ease also alleges that Transitions
refused to deal with competitors or customers who offered “competitive
products, exclusionary contracts, and tying arrangements and bundled
discounts.”
A Transitions spokesperson said in response to the lawsuit,
“While we do not typically comment on pending litigation, we can say
that the Vision-Ease case seems to us to be lacking in merit, and we
expect to defend it vigorously.”
The Vision-Ease suit follows a settlement between the Federal
Trade Commission and Transitions Optical announced in March that bars
Transitions Optical from using allegedly anticompetitive practices to
maintain its monopoly and increase prices on photochromic lenses. Since
then, a number of optical retailers from throughout the U.S. have filed
suit against Transitions for alleged antitrust violations.
■
■